Solar Flare: Science Fiction News

Avatar

Providing the Information That Sci-Fi Fans Need

Doctor Who: Dalek, Review

Dalek must have been the most eagerly anticipated episode of the new Doctor Who series after the Rose. It faced an uphill battle. The Dalek’s carry with them huge expectations, they are also a substantial liability. By taking the Dalek’s out of their usual environment and emphasizing just how dangerous a single Dalek can be they handled this superbly.

In order to make Daleks work for the new Doctor Who, the writers had to find a way to not only re-imagine them for a modern audience, but also to push them beyond their ham-fisted stereotype. We all know that the Daleks are “Nazis”. We know they come in and scream “Exterminate” but they have always lacked depth. In fact the Dalek story generally regarded as the best, Genesis of the Daleks, introduced a spokesperson for the Daleks precisely because of their limitations.

So with all that to work against, how did Dalek fair? Remarkably well actually. For a starter, the story was not just fast paced but genuinely tense in places. There were some emotional scenes as well and the time taken in earlier episodes to establish the close relationship between Rose and the Doctor really paid off here.

Visually this episode was wonderful. Past Doctor Who directors would love to have been able to do with the Daleks what they did here. This solitary, damaged (and insane) Dalek was powerful, unstoppable and scary. The scene where it levitates off the floor and electrocutes everyone in the room was breathtaking.

Not content with rehabilitating the Daleks, this story actually draws parallels between the Doctor and his arch-enemies. Once upon a time the Doctor refused to destroy the Daleks because he didn’t have the right. That was several regenerations ago. Since then he has destroyed their planet, they have destroyed his race and he apparently attempted genocide. At one point the Dalek remarks that the Doctor would make a good Dalek. It’s a shocking statement, and yet, it rings true.

The episode is not perfect mind you. Doctor Who has always had more than its share of technobabble and dubious science, but I think the notion of “absorbing the metabolism of a time traveler” to restore a Dalek may just take the cake. And we’d better not touch the notion of plugging into the electricity grid and sucking down all the information on the internet.

Over all though I think this is the strongest episode of what has been an impressive Doctor Who season so far and the teaser for the next week looks very interesting too.

Eoghann Irving is amongst other things the creator and Editor of Solar Flare. He has a life long interest in all forms of science fiction and fantasy and a pressing need to share this interest with anyone who will listen. Find out more at his personal website eoghann.com..

Like It? Share It!
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
  • TwitThis
  • Mixx


One Comment, Comment or Ping

  1. The episode is not perfect mind you. Doctor Who has always had more than its share of technobabble and dubious science, but I think the notion of “absorbing the metabolism of a time traveler” to restore a Dalek may just take the cake.

    I agree. And the thing is, the series had already set a precident for us that could have made this work (and this is all reenforced in the final episode of the season.) It was already established that Rose has a psychic link with the TARDIS. The Dalek needed to genetically evolve itself based upon Rose’s DNA so that it could piggy-back onto that connection and steal power from the TARDIS.

    It was the TARDIS that rejuvenated the Dalek, not Rose’s DNA.

    That would be how I would have explained it.

    Maybe the show needs a technical advisor. Someone who looks at the scripts for things like this and tries to provide solutions.

    Another mistake was in “Bad Wolf” when the Doctor says that the Dalek fleet is hidden from “SONAR”. This is just really bad science. Unless SONAR stands for something different in the Doctor Who universe, it just won’t work in space. The line could have so easily been changed to:

    “The signal hides it… from visual perception, RADAR, scanner, everything…”

    Substitute “visual perception” for “SONAR” and you’re good to go.

Reply to “Doctor Who: Dalek, Review”